Whodunit Short Stories: Who Done It, Howdunit, Inverted Detective & New or Modern Sherlock Holmes Mystery

These short stories have a mystery that gets investigated, often a crime of some sort. The focus is on who committed the crime or how it was carried out, or how a particular situation was resolved.

Want to test your own “whodunit” skills? Check out Murder at the Chessboard for 43 short mystery puzzles.

“The Bothersome Business of the Dutch Nativity” by Derek Wilson

Watson tells the story of Holmes’s lost first case. Holmes was enrolled at Grenville College. While riding the train he impressed a man, William Spooner, of New College with his deductive skills. Spooner takes the opportunity to enlist his help with a problem. A valuable Rembrandt painting, Nativity, was stolen from the college. There’s been a spate of similar incidents at other colleges. They’ll only be able to keep it quiet for so long.

This story can be read in the preview of The Mammoth Book of New Sherlock Holmes Adventures.

“The Adventure of the Crimson Arrow” by Denis Smith

Sir George invites notable citizens to his country estate for the weekend. One of the traditions is an archery contest, as Sir George has taken an interest in the sport. One of his guests is Woodforde Soames, the renowned African explorer. On the following Monday, Watson reads in the paper that one of Sir George’s guests was killed by an arrow. They soon learn that Scotland Yard was called and an arrest was made.

This story can be read in the preview of The Mammoth Book of the Lost Chronicles of Sherlock Holmes.

“The Tuesday Night Club” by Agatha Christie

A group of friends are socializing at the home of Miss Marple when the conversation turns to unsolved mysteries. Each member of the group believes their profession gives them an advantage in crime solving. They decide to take turns telling a crime mystery of which the teller knows the solution. Then they will put their perceptive powers to the test and try to identify the real culprit.

In this first story, Mr. and Mrs. Jones and Miss Clark get sick after supper, and Mrs. Jones dies. Suspicion falls on Mr. Jones because he was dependent on his wife’s money, and due to a letter he wrote. Nothing solidly implicates him for the crime.

This story can be read in the preview of Miss Marple: The Complete Stories(Kindle version)

“The Bone-Headed League” by Lee Child

An FBI agent who thoroughly enjoys England is assigned to the embassy in London. The work is easy. He liaises with the police when Americans are involved in a crime. One day, he’s called to Baker Street by Scotland Yard. Some details of the case are obvious references to a story he’s familiar with. His enthusiasm for British things takes over.

This story can be read in the preview of The Mammoth Book of Best British Crime 10.

“The Case of the Middle-Aged Wife” by Agatha Christie

Mr. Packington leaves for work. Mrs. Packington sits at the kitchen table, first angry and then sad. She reads an ad in the paper by Parker Pyne, who claims he can help unhappy people. She goes to his office. He knows some of her experiences and concerns without being told. He believes he can help her, but his fee is too high.

This story can be read in the preview of Parker Pyne Investigates: A Short Story Collection.

“The Coming of Mr. Quin” by Agatha Christie

Some acquaintances are gathered at Royston, hosted by the Evesham’s, Tom and Laura. Also present is Sir Richard, who is a soldier and traveler, the Portals, and Mr. Satterthwaite, an observant man. He notices Mrs. Portal. Conversation turns to Mr. Capel, the man who used to own the house. He shot himself.

This story can be read in the preview of The Mysterious Mr. Quin: A Short Story Collection.

“The Wild Adventure of the Indigo Impossibility” by Will Murray

Watson finds Holmes pondering an extraordinary case. The papers are reporting that people in Thundersley are being killed by an unknown creature. It walks on two legs, is a deep indigo color and has claws. Holmes is going to investigate in the morning.

Some of this story can be read in the preview of The Wild adventures of Sherlock Holmes.

“Slippery Fingers” by Dashiell Hammett

Frederick Grover’s father is found dead in his home on Sunday morning, stabbed with a paper-knife. He had recently withdrawn $10,000 from his bank. Fingerprints at the scene don’t match any of the likely suspects. The Continental Op is called in.

Read “Slippery Fingers”

If you like this character, all the stories are available in The Big Book of the Continental Op.

“The Marshalsea Handicap” by Gillian Linscott

The narrator has prepared odds on five inmates of Marshalsea Debtor’s Prison. Mr. Shipman, who they call Father Christmas, has a yearly tradition—he selects one man and pays off his debt. There’s discussion about who is likely to be picked this year. One of the inmates, Mr. Dickens, has a son named Charlie who has impressed Mr. Shipman.

This story can be read in the preview of Dickensian Whodunnits.

“The Affair at the Victory Ball” by Agatha Christie

Chief Inspector Japp brings Hercule Poirot in on a baffling case. While attending a costume ball a man is found stabbed. After being taken home a woman is found dead in her bed from a cocaine overdose.

Read “The Affair at the Victory Ball” (first story in preview)

“His Master’s Servant” by Philip Boast

Sir Roger, a Christian knight, prays at the Templar fortress in the Holy Land. His servant calls him for an urgent meeting. The men are all asleep and it’s very quiet. Sir Roger goes to Gondemar’s quarters and is led into the sanctum; Gondemar has ensured secrecy. Sir Roger is shocked to see the King, and even more shocked to see the other guest.

Most of this story can be read in the preview of The Mammoth Book of Historical Whodunnits Volume 3.

“Wish You Were Here” by Frank Jones

A woman buys an unusual garden gnome, but it disappears soon after. She starts getting postcards that are signed from the gnome.

Read “Wish You Were Here”

“The Witness for the Prosecution” by Agatha Christie

Leonard Vole has been charged with murder, and the case against him is strong. His solicitor, Mr. Mayherne, stresses the importance of frankness—the more he knows, the stronger the defense he can mount. It all started when Leonard did a good deed to an elderly woman. As he tells the story, it turns out the case against him is even worse than he thought.

A lot of this story can be read in the preview of The Witness for the Prosecution and Other Stories. (10% into preview)

“The Crooked Man” by Arthur Conan Doyle

Colonel James Barkley is found dead in his home, and his wife, Nancy, is the prime suspect. Holmes is called to investigate.

Read “The Crooked Man”

“The Bruce-Partington Plans” by Arthur Conan Doyle

Holmes is bored with the caliber of crime in London when he receives a telegram informing him of an urgent visit from his brother Mycroft. A young man was found dead on the train tracks. He had on him the plans for a top secret government submarine; the most important pages were missing.

Read “The Bruce-Partington Plans”

“The Jewel Robbery at the Grand Metropolitan” by Agatha Christie

Poirot meets the Opalsen’s at a hotel. Mrs. Opalsen insists on showing Poirot some of her jewels. She runs up to her room to get them. Shortly after, a page boy summons Mr. Opalsen upstairs. Poirot notices increased activity among the staff and realizes something has happened.

Read “The Jewel Robbery at the Grand Metropolitan” (second story in preview)

“The Adventure of the Speckled Band” by Arthur Conan Doyle

A young woman, Helen, makes an early morning visit to Holmes and Watson. She lives with her stepfather, who is known for his outbursts. Her sister died two years before in their home. Her dying words referred to a speckled band. She was engaged at the time. Now, Helen is also engaged, and she’s heard the same type of noise her sister mentioned before she died.

Read “The Adventure of the Speckled Band”

“The Adventure of the Dancing Men” by Arthur Conan Doyle

Holmes shows Watson a piece of paper with drawings of stick figures that look like dancing men. Watson believes them to be a child’s work. Mr. Cubitt has sent it to Holmes, and he’ll be arriving shortly. He’s been finding them around his house, and they seem to mean something to his wife, Elsie.

Read “The Adventure of the Dancing Men”

“The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds” by Neil Gaiman

A private detective sits in his office drinking and cleaning his gun. A beautiful woman comes in and shows him a picture of a dead man. She says he was her brother. The death was ruled an accident but she believes he was murdered.

Read “The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds”

“The Necklace of Pearls” by Dorothy L. Sayers

Sir Septimus throws an annual old-fashioned Christmas party at his country house. After the dinner he likes to play the same games each year. On Christmas Eve he also has the tradition of giving his daughter Margharita a pearl for her necklace. This year, in addition to the three members of his family, he has eleven guests. During the evening, it’s noted that something has gone missing.

Read “The Necklace of Pearls”

“Maddened by Mystery: or The Defective Detective” by Stephen Leacock

The Great Detective is sitting in his office when a baffling case is presented to him. The Prince of Wurttemberg has been kidnapped. The Great Detective devotes the full power of his analytical brain to the case.

This story is a parody of Sherlock Holmes.

It’s the first story in the preview of Complete Nonsense Novels.